| Platinum | LA Bottega |
| Gold | Galeotti's |
| Silver | Galeotti's Wine Cellar |
| Bronze | Pizzeria LA Sorrentina |
| Top Pick | Blazzin Pizza |
| Top Pick | Little Italy's Trattoria |
| Top Pick | NYC Pizzaria |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Blind Onion Pizza & Pub |
| Top Pick | The Old Spaghetti Factory |