| Platinum | The Megabite Orchards |
| Gold | The Megabite Hazeldell |
| Silver | N.Y.C. Pizza |
| Bronze | Leonardo's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Blazzin Pizza |
| Top Pick | Blind Onion Pizza |
| Top Pick | Doomsday Pizza and Pub |
| Top Pick | Juliano's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Pizzeria LA Sorrentina |
| Top Pick | Vault 31 |